Forum of Design for the Public Realm
Places
AboutFoundation
Partner Schools
Print Archive
Peer Review
Submissions
Donate
Contact
Departments
CritiqueEssays
Gallery
Interviews
Multimedia
Partner News
Peer Reviewed
Poetry & Fiction
Projects
Topics
ArchitectureArt
Books
Cities / Places
Community
Culture
Design History
Design Practice
Development
Ecology
Economy
Education
Energy
Environment
Film / Video
Food/Agriculture
Geography
Health / Safety
History
Housing
Ideas
Infrastructure
Landscape
Photography
Planning
Politics / Policy
Preservation
Public / Private
Reputations
Sustainability
Technology
Theory/Criticism
Transportation
Urbanism
Water
Design Observer
ArchiveBooks + Store
Job Board
Email Archive
Comments
About
Contact
Log In
Register
Critique: Beth Weinstein
The City's End
Atta Kim, Fifth Avenue and 57th Street, 2006.
(O, New York) How do I love thee? Let me count the ways.I love thee to the depth and breadth (of thine bedrock) and height (of thine skyscrapers.
I flatter you with poems, films, and I ♥ everything. I love you because you are the expression of my greatest hopes for mankind).
— Elizabeth Barrett Browning (sort of)
New York City's narcissism can be counted in its many depictions. We become its icons by sporting foam lady-liberty crowns. We reminisce about urban pasts we never knew, leafing through thousand-page documentary tomes that chronicle each building and street, every great figure and robber baron who ever trod there. Adoration of the great metropolis is found in every possible media. The city and its representations reflect our highest aspirations for our selves and our society. And as its achievements reflect our own, so too its fall is tantamount to the fall of civilization. Thus embedded within the imagination of the city's destruction, its causes and aftermath, is a registration of the anxiety of the generation that is imagining the city's end.
Representations of the demise of New York City, in literary works, graphic media and moving pictures, and what follows that demise, are the subject of Max Page’s most recent book, The City’s End: Two Centuries of Fantasies, Fears, and Premonitions of New York’s Destruction [Yale University Press, 2008].
Page sets the stage by exploring "disaster porn" — that peculiarly American genre obsessed with destruction and rebirth. New York, he argues, is consistently the most popular locus of epic-scaled depictions of destruction, largely because the nation's cultural and economic capital is the most obvious focus of such American issues as " . . . ambivalence towards cities, the troubled reaction to immigrants and racial diversity, the fear of technology’s impact, and the apocalyptic strain in American religious life." [p. 4]
Louis Guglielmi, Mental Geography, 1938.
Each epoch or generation's rendition of New York's end is here presented as a social-psychological barometer, a measure of mass fears and fantasies. Anxiety about the city's readiness to cope with attack long predates the events of September 11, 2001. From the 18th century to the present, Page points out, preparedness, as concept and reality, has been an always ungraspable goal, given the city's escalating and diversifying population as well as the rise of increasingly unruly means of destruction, in the hands of real or imaginary enemies. These enemies — roughly categorized as foreign or domestic strangers, beasts, natural phenomena and mankind's own inventions — shape-shift across time, ranging from warships to airships and UFOs; from the Horrible Huns to diverse ethnic others to Martians and post-nuclear mutants; from earthquakes that topple buildings to global-warming-caused tsunamis that inundate them. Through portraying and narrating the city's destruction, and the life that emerges from the ruins, the diverse works referenced here give voice and image to contemporaneous fears; and by suggesting the degree of destruction required to begin anew, they also implicitly critique the ills of the society that was destroyed.
In the decades around the dawn of the last century, diverse fears were fueling the creative fires. These include the potential of foreign attack by the then-new technology of the airplane, as portrayed in H.G. Wells's War in the Air, of 1908; the eruption of race and draft riots at home, seen in works by such writers as W.E.B. DuBois and Arthur Vinton; the toppling of Tammany, portrayed in Thomas Nast’s 1871 cartoon Something That Did Blow Over, and the crashing stock market, symbolized in the teetering skyscrapers of Jose Clemente Orozco's 1931 Los Muertos. In fantasy, nature would also take its toll on the city. Great beasts (such as King Kong, in both the original 1933 movie and the '76 remake), meteor showers (in W.E.B. Du Bois's short story The Comet), and floods worthy of Noah's Ark (in Deluge, another '33 film) — all these would wipe out the evils of the great metropolis, permitting an elite few to survive and to found a new, inevitably purer, more ethical society upon the city's ashes or in the greener pastures beyond the Hudson River.
In the decades around the dawn of the last century, diverse fears were fueling the creative fires. These include the potential of foreign attack by the then-new technology of the airplane, as portrayed in H.G. Wells's War in the Air, of 1908; the eruption of race and draft riots at home, seen in works by such writers as W.E.B. DuBois and Arthur Vinton; the toppling of Tammany, portrayed in Thomas Nast’s 1871 cartoon Something That Did Blow Over, and the crashing stock market, symbolized in the teetering skyscrapers of Jose Clemente Orozco's 1931 Los Muertos. In fantasy, nature would also take its toll on the city. Great beasts (such as King Kong, in both the original 1933 movie and the '76 remake), meteor showers (in W.E.B. Du Bois's short story The Comet), and floods worthy of Noah's Ark (in Deluge, another '33 film) — all these would wipe out the evils of the great metropolis, permitting an elite few to survive and to found a new, inevitably purer, more ethical society upon the city's ashes or in the greener pastures beyond the Hudson River.
Thomas Nast, "Something That Did Blow Over," Harper's Weekly, 1871.
In the 1940s and '50s, both high and low forms of cultural production drew upon the fears of the atomic age. In the 1952 sci-fi movie Invasion USA, a hydrogen bomb is dropped on Midtown Manhattan, destroying Rockefeller Center, among other targets. An early episode of Rod Serling's TV series The Twilight Zone grappled with the more invisible enemy of nuclear radiation. And Ralph E. Lapp's somber 1949 book, Must We Hide?, tolled a death knell for American cities, with its proposal for a planned decentralization that might "reduce the attractiveness of our cities to a point that they are not worthy of an atomic bomb." [p. 125]. Page insightfully — and poignantly — links popular representations of a post-apocalyptic or declining New York, in movies like Planet of the Apes (1968), Fort Apache, The Bronx (1981) and Escape from New York (1981), to the city’s economic collapse and racial tensions of the '60s and '70s, and the resulting white flight to suburbia. These depictions of New York as a dangerous, abandoned wasteland blurred reality and fiction. Yet even in recent years, despite the disappearance of visible threats and the resurgent population and prosperity, the drive to destroy the city persists, whether by the green slime of Ghost Busters or the malevolent aliens of Independence Day.
To track the abundance of cited poems, novels, newspaper illustrations, essays, paintings, films and both printed and animated comics, Page provides for the curious a thorough index and ample notes at the end of the book. The City’s End is also extremely well illustrated, with both black-and-white and color reproductions from diverse works. But its very wealth of material can be overwhelming, and in navigating Page's Rabelaisian thicket, one finds redundancies from chapter to chapter, as though each were developed in isolation and not reworked as a single, fluid text.
Throughout the book — threading together the discussion of fears and fantasies across the generations — Page references the time he spent airborne in the Microsoft flight simulator, and describes the allure of flying his virtual Cessna around and between the city’s skyscrapers, into the towers. This prepares the ground to address the always hovering topic of the real destruction that occurred on September 11, 2001, in the context of the irrepressible urge to destroy the city in film, comics, literature, painting, et al. Inevitably one asks: How have the production and nature of post–9/11 fantasies been transformed by those truly destructive events? Cease they did not; such fantasies were perhaps momentarily silenced, or diverted (as was Page’s own plan to curate an exhibit titled Destroying New York). Disaster-porn thrives, at once an expression of American optimism (and perhaps naïveté), of our can-do attitude and ultimate belief in fresh starts and the super-hero-style fulfillment of one's potential in Gotham City.
Ralph E. Lapp, "Before" and "after" illustrations from Must We Hide?, 1949.
An implicit question emerges as one reads: Why New York, and not Rome or Tokyo or Paris? Rome was famously sacked and re-emerged, so there’s no fantasy to be had there. Tokyo and Paris are both too flat; they've got no tall buildings, except the Eiffel Tower, for super-heroes to leap over or supporting characters to fall from (as is suggested in Laurie Anderson’s O Superman). New York — with its density, its heights and depths of ambition and achievement, its ego, wealth, and skyline — creates a dramatically varied setting for heroic action. More important, perhaps, through the experience of film, literature and diverse popular media, we are all New Yorkers. We walk its streets weekly on crime dramas and sit-coms, we ride its subway trains in music. Whether real or vicarious New Yorkers, we identify with the city's glory and with its downfall.
According to Max Page, anyone who has spent enough time in New York to see some once-familiar place torn down and replaced is, by definition, a New Yorker. Our love and attachment to the great city grows stronger with the loss of some neighborhood joint or iconic building and the creation there of something new. Our New York is always being ripped down and updated, offering up new sites upon which to construct memories and fantasies. New York is in a state of perpetual reconstruction. It's said that O Henry quipped, "This city will be a great place if they ever finish it." To keep it a work in progress, some part of New York is always being undone.
Subscribe to Comment Feed
Comments (4) | JUMP TO MOST RECENT >>
sorry it's suppose to read
"... even excluding Godzilla and Grave of the Fireflies"".
"... even excluding Godzilla and Grave of the Fireflies"".
Great article. The photo tells the whole story. New York is such an Iconic city, I have lost count of the times it is represented in cinema. For me a a kid, the end scene of Planet of the apes, with the half buried Statue of liberty was a stunning shot.
This article shows us that even though many of us can love a place for the things that are wonderful, we still want to change things so we "create" disasters to destroy so what we believe needs to be changed can be.
LOG IN TO POST A COMMENT
Don't have an account? Create an account. Forgot your password? Click here.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Beth Weinstein was a project architect in the Paris office of Jean Nouvel before founding her own practice, Architecture Agency, which focuses on collaborations with visual and performing artists. She is an Assistant Professor of Architecture at the University of Arizona.More Bio >>
DESIGN OBSERVER JOBS
MORE ON New York City
Seagram: Union of Building and Landscape
On Places, Phyllis Lambert explores the evolution of the Seagram Building, focusing on Mies van der Rohe's profound concern for the relationship between building and nature.
Past Perfect: Four Freedoms Park
On Places, Belmont Freeman reviews the controversial politics of presidential memorials, focusing especially on Four Freedoms Park in New York City, the memorial to FDR designed 40 years by Louis Kahn.
Occupying Wall Street: Places and Spaces of Political Action
On Places, Jonathan Massey and Brett Snyder explore the physical places and virtual spaces of Occupy Wall Street — the "hypercity built of granite and asphalt, algorithms and information."
Occupy: The Day After
On Places, Reinhold Martin explores how Occupy Wall Street might challenge the structural inequities of finance capitalism, and how architects and urbanists can contribute to the next phase of the movement
Occupy: What Architecture Can Do
On Places, Reinhold Martin explores the role of architecture in the Occupy Wall Street movement — and in the larger challenges of constructing a better and more equitable society.
Above Grade: On the High Line
On Places, writer Phillip Lopate traces the pre-history of the High Line, and ponders whether New York City's elevated park will be a victim of its own success.
The Art of Advocacy: The Museum as Design Laboratory
On Places, MoMA's curator of architecture and design, Barry Bergdoll, describes his efforts to expand the museum's role to support experimentation and advocacy.
Queer Beacon
On Places, architect Kian Goh explores LGBT public spaces in contemporary New York, where activism confronts gentrification.
Gita Lenz: New York Views
On Places, a gallery by the mid-century New York photographer Gita Lenz, whose long neglected work is gaining new recognition.
Jane Jacobs, Andy Warhol, and the Kind of Problem a Community Is
On Places, Tim Mennel compares the radically different New York worlds of Andy Warhol's Factory and Jane Jacobs's Village — and comes to some provocative conclusions.
Jane Jacobs and the Death and Life of American Planning
On Places, Thomas Campanella evaluates the complex legacy Jane Jacobs, including the ongoing marginalization of the urban planning profession.
Street Cred
On Places, Mimi Zeiger reviews Street Value, the new book about Downtown Brooklyn and the dynamic interplay of shopping and planning, of politics and race and class.
What's Going On in the Garment District?
On Places, an interactive section created by the Brooklyn-based Interboro Partners offers a detailed look at "what's going on in the garment district" of Manhattan.
Hallowed Ground, Worldly City: Ground Zero and the Struggle for Lower Manhattan
On Places, James Sanders looks at the current controversy over the proposed Islamic center near Ground Zero in a larger context, noting that New York City has for most of its history "abhorred the very idea of memorials."
The Water Underground
On Places, watch The Water Underground, a video from the Center for Urban Pedagogy that tracks the complex — and contested — systems of water supply, treatment and waste that serve New York City.
Green Metropolis
On Places, urban planning professor Timothy Beatley, author of Green Urbanism, reviews Green Metropolis, by David Owen, which argues that Manhattan is the greenest city in the U.S.
Two Feet High and Rising: On Optimism, Speculation and Oysters
On Places, Mimi Zeiger reviews MoMA's ambitious new architecture and urban design show, Rising Currents: Projects for New York's Waterfront, which explores how New York Harbor might be adapted in the face of rising sea levels.
Bodega Down Bronx
Why is it easier to get fresh produce in Park Slope than in the South Bronx? Places presents Bodega Down Bronx, a video from the Center for Urban Pedagogy, that examines where and why New York's bodegas get their food.
The Past Is Promenade: On the High Line
Architect Ian Baldwin contemplates the High Line and sees in New York's newest park a rare and valuable form of urban place: a slow corridor.
On the Water: The New York/New Jersey Harbor
As the planet warms, rising seas will endanger coastal communities around the world. Engineer Guy Nordenson proposes a bold plan to protect New York City.
MORE BY Beth Weinstein
03.07.11: The Collaborative Legacy of Merce Cunningham05.17.10: Self-Fab House
More by Beth Weinstein >>
RELATED POSTS
Digital Deception
On Places, Belmont Freeman argues it's time to grapple with the artistic and professional consequences — and ethical dilemmas — of today's ever more powerful digital rendering technologies.
Please Save Modernism from the Modern
On Places, David Heymann makes the case for why the Folk Art Museum is a great modernist building — and why the Museum of Modern Art should reverse its decision to tear it down.
Child’s Play
On Places, Naomi Stead examines the cultural perception of architecture as not simply a creative profession but also a kind of child's play — an uber-kindergarten legitimated for academic credit and professional reputation.
The Emergence of Container Urbanism
On Places, Mitchell Schwarzer charts the rise of container urbanism from the mid 20th century to now, focusing especially on the dynamic potential of repurposed shipping containers to shape a new kind of city life.
Public and Common(s)
On Places, Reinhold Martin explores the philosophical understandings of the terms public and commons, from the 20th-century treatises of Arendt and Habermas to recent books by Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri.
You site Tokyo as an example of non heroic tales of death and re-birth but I think that this is purely from a western point of view. There are many apocalyptic tales (even heroic ones) from eastern culture... even excluding and "Grave of the Fireflies".
You can also look at any community or population around the globe and see a sense of growth and loss that exists as something connected with it's population's feeling of ownership and pride surrounding their living spaces. Godzilla
01.19.10 at 07:12