Partner Schools
Print Archive
Peer Review


Partner News
Peer Reviewed
Poetry & Fiction


Cities + Places
Design History
Design Practice
Film + Video
Health + Safety
Politics + Policy
Public + Private

Design Observer

Job Board

Comments (1) Posted 12.20.10 | PERMALINK | PRINT

Critique: Mark Lamster and Alexandra Lange

Lunch with the Critics: Northwest Corner Building, Columbia University

Northwest Corner Building, Columbia University, view from Broadway. [Photo: Michael Moran]

Columbia University recently opened an 188,000-square-foot interdisciplinary science building at the northwest corner of its McKim, Mead and White-planned Morningside Heights Campus. The 14-story building, designed by Pritzker Prize-winning architect Rafael Moneo (with Moneo Brock Studio and Davis Brody Bond Aedas), completes the perimeter of the campus, and contains research labs, faculty offices, a science library, lecture hall and café, along with links to existing academic buildings. After a tour of the building with Moneo and his associated architects, Alexandra Lange and Mark Lamster sat down for a sandwich in the cafeteria of Avery Hall, home to Columbia’s architecture school, to review what they’d seen.

Alexandra Lange: I have to admit that I've been prejudiced against this building for a while. Its Broadway facade — pink diagonal saw-tooth granite on the lower two floors, stainless steel diagonal louvers above — seemed so cluelessly forbidding, I had written the building off as an oncoming PR disaster. I wrote earlier this year about the b.s. quality of the ground-level transparency at Barnard's Diana Center across Broadway — it may be literally transparent, but you can't get in from the street; but still, it seemed insane for Columbia to continue its walled tradition onto its last open corner at 120th Street.

And in fact, those lower stone floors are a problem. The stone notches back at the corner, where a cantilevered glass piano nobile, holding the café, juts out over the building's entrance (also glass), but it remains fortress-like along much of the western flank. Where it does open up is to the north, where the entrance and café are intended to be a southern beacon for the occupants of Columbia's 21st-century campus, up in Manhattanville, a.k.a., West Harlem.

They even brought [Columbia president] Lee Bollinger in to talk to us architecture writers to make sure we got the message: 20th-century Columbia is complete, long live Manhattanville! I could have done without the sense of entitlement and manifest destiny, given how Columbia got control of those additional 17 acres. I just hope they don't build any pink granite walls up there, however stylishly textured.

Mark Lamster: That prejudice, and I think a lot of people share it, was the starting point of my review of the building for Architectural Review. This is not the building most New Yorkers were expecting from either Moneo or Columbia. I think there was an expectation of something contextual, something maybe in brick or stone, materials Moneo is known for handling with such aplomb. As it is, aside from the granite base — a failed nod to that contextualism — it’s almost a defiantly high-tech building, like something from the desk of Norman Foster. I've heard that some of the science people here are calling it the "heat sink."

But just because a building defies expectations doesn't mean it's not good. This project was charged with so many difficult tasks. A science building is a tough program on its own; then throw in the requirement of making an iconic new entry to the campus while negotiating a grade change — that’s a lot to ask. For the most part, it’s effective. (The students here at Avery would do well to learn from it.) Certainly it’s complex — a three-dimensional jigsaw puzzle wedged into a tiny lot set above the school gym, which had to remain open during construction. Even Moneo, during our tour, had a hard time explaining how it worked in his somewhat halting English. He’s so charming, though, I just wanted to give him a cuddle.

Section, NWC Building. Courtesy Moneo Brock Studio.

AL: That's true, and that's why tours with the architects are often a bad idea. So many charming men are such terrible architects. Moneo isn't one of them, but he may have been given a task impossible to carry off.

For example, you asked him why he chose marble for that double-height lobby. Like the northern glass facade, it is supposed to be an open space through which members of the Columbia and Harlem communities can flow in and up to the rest of the campus. He said something about how it was a public space — hence marble. To me, the striated white and gray marble, which is shiny and applied like wallpaper, suggests mausoleum, not café. The built-in marble kitchen is like one of those Bulthaup ads in Elle Decor — an antiseptic bachelor pad. The elegant white Artemide KAO light fixture, deployed as a Richard Lippold sculpture might have been in a mid-century corporate lobby, only increases the chilliness.

Belen Moneo, a collaborator on the building (and Rafael's daughter), said they plan to furnish the room with white Vegetal chairs by the Bouroullec brothers. I was dying for something to warm it up. Shag rugs! Red sofas! The colorless space's lack of visual drama from the street makes it hard to imagine it will draw outsiders in, or smooth the awkward path from 120th and Broadway up to the campus. Given the engineering constraints you describe, there wasn't a way to make the path smooth. You have to enter, turn left, go up some stairs, go up an escalator, turn left again to get to the upper level of the main campus. I am sure students will find some simpler path of desire and start taking that instead.

Labs, NWC Building. [Photo: Michael Moran]

ML: How well it works as a pathway remains to be seen; there aren't too many better options, so I wouldn't be so quick to dismiss this one. The switchbacks are perhaps lamentable, but an unavoidable cost of a restricted lot, the major grade shift from street to campus, and the imposition of the you-can't-touch-it gymnasium. And I'm not quite sure that marble is so funereal as you suggest. Columbia spent a good deal of money on all that stone, and I think that speaks to their aspirations for the room as a civic space. With some attractive Columbia students lounging about the French seating and sipping lattes, it might be a good deal more appealing than you suspect.

I asked Moneo about all that marble because it's quite different in character from the other public spaces of the building, in particular the library and the very beautiful auditorium, which seem almost Scandinavian to me, with so much blonde wood furnishing and natural light.

AL: I agree completely about the library and auditorium. Indeed, it was when we got up to the third (or was it fourth?) floor, and sat in the sturdy, handsome booths for collaborative study in the library, that my prejudice began to dissipate. The spaces for students, the materials used, the ease of access from the rest of Columbia's campus: all of these were thoughtful and beautiful. I'd love to work in the (practically bookless) library, with its clear view across Barnard and Union Theological Seminary to the river. That floor is the one place you can look both off and on campus.

I love that you can go directly from the campus level into the elevators and up to your lab. The auditorium was lovely, warm and wood-lined. Its angles reminded me of Marcel Breuer's Begrisch Hall at Bronx Community College, but this space is much cozier. That all made perfect sense and the labs we saw had great views and clear organization. Even the linoleum looked expensive. Of course, scientists are notorious for lowering the shades on exterior windows forever, so we will see how long the windows remain clear.

What didn't seem so nice was the classroom we saw, part of a link to an existing science building. Tiny, hot from a whole wall of south-facing windows. While the Broadway facade seems fortress-like, the campus facade is a fairly generic glass curtain wall, facing east, that seems destined to heat all the faculty offices to broil. It shows the building's big trusses, but in no way says science, or Columbia, or even academia. I'm not asking for professorial brick applique, but some inflection toward type and use.

Library, NWC Building. [Photo: Michael Moran]

Classroom, NWC Building. [Photo: Mark Lamster]

ML: Let's just belabor, for a moment, how impressive those laboratories are, because they are the raison d'etre of this building. Moneo's ability as a space planner really shows in the disposition of the academic spaces. The double-height labs run the length of the building, and sit across from a bi-level stack of faculty offices and student workstations. As it's arranged, each professor will have an office right across the hall from his or her lab, with grad students conveniently placed right above. A brain scientist I chatted up on our tour seemed very happy with his new digs. Maybe, in this stimulating new atmosphere, he'll finally figure out why I'm always losing my keys.

Otherwise, the facade on the campus side isn't super-expressive, you're right, and leaves me a bit apprehensive about the harsh light that's going to hit the faculty offices, and also the plunging shadows that will be cast by the aluminum louvers on either side of the building.

AL: So maybe the problem of the Northwest Corner Building — a name that suggests: we’re still waiting for a donor to ante up — is that it couldn't possibly do all that it has been asked to do. Moneo gave them an excellent urban academic building, thanks to some virtuoso trusses and stacking. What he couldn't do is to fix Columbia's stone base and make a warm, inviting crossroads for a campus that doesn't yet exist — Manhattanville — and a community that's still suspicious. We'll see what happens, five years from now, when the first building (scheduled to be a neuroscience facility) opens uptown and the northwest corner becomes, for some, the southeast entrance. For now, I'm happy for the scientists.

ML: Fair enough. I will say the place is growing on me, so I’m curious as to how it will develop as the school expands. I’ll see you here again in 2015.

Share This Story


Why Architects Need Feminism

The Demolition and Afterlife of Baltimore Memorial Stadium

Head of the Dragon: The Rise of New Shanghai

Implausible Futures for Unpopular Places

The Anti-Monograph

RSSSubscribe to Comment Feed

Comments (1)   |   JUMP TO MOST RECENT >>

I lived several blocks to the south of this new building over the past three years and watched its massive cantilevered frame and later its tech louvered facade going up. I'm not familiar with the building's program but agree that the stone base, while contextual with the original campus, is a problem for the streetscape.

Columbia U's original campus designers wanted the public to enter into the central court and from there into the individual campus buildings - an interesting riff on inward looking Medieval campus plan precedent. But this new building by Moneo isn't accessed from a central court, but from the street, making the fortress like perimeter wall a 'let's make it contextual' afterthought. I think it very possible that the architect was pressured by a University design review committee to contextualize. An architect of his stature shouldn't be designing by committee.
Peter Rudd
12.24.10 at 06:11

Don't have an account? Create an account. Forgot your password? Click here.



Donate to Places: Your Support Makes Our Work Possible


More Bio >>

More Bio >>


MORE ON New York City

"The moment for something to happen"
On Places, Belmont Freeman reviews The Making of an Avant-Garde, Diana Agrest's new documentary on the Institute for Architecture and Urban Studies, from its 1970s heyday to its brilliant legacy.

Resilience in Red Hook
On Places, Alexandros Washburn, chief urban designer for New York, describes the frightening onset and complicated aftermath of Hurricane Sandy, which devastated the city last October.

The City and the Sea
On Places, Tom Vanderbilt surveys the landscape and politics of New York City after Hurricane Sandy, focusing on both early response and long-range planning.

An Interview with David Burney: On New York and the 21st-Century City-State
On Places, an interview with New York City Design and Construction Commissioner David Burney, who reflects on the urban design record of the Bloomberg years, the post-Sandy recovery effort, and the rise of the 21st-century city-state.

Seagram: Union of Building and Landscape
On Places, Phyllis Lambert explores the evolution of the Seagram Building, focusing on Mies van der Rohe's profound concern for the relationship between building and nature.

Past Perfect: Four Freedoms Park
On Places, Belmont Freeman reviews the controversial politics of presidential memorials, focusing especially on Four Freedoms Park in New York City, the memorial to FDR designed 40 years by Louis Kahn.

Occupying Wall Street: Places and Spaces of Political Action
On Places, Jonathan Massey and Brett Snyder explore the physical places and virtual spaces of Occupy Wall Street — the "hypercity built of granite and asphalt, algorithms and information."

Occupy: The Day After
On Places, Reinhold Martin explores how Occupy Wall Street might challenge the structural inequities of finance capitalism, and how architects and urbanists can contribute to the next phase of the movement

Occupy: What Architecture Can Do
On Places, Reinhold Martin explores the role of architecture in the Occupy Wall Street movement — and in the larger challenges of constructing a better and more equitable society.

Above Grade: On the High Line
On Places, writer Phillip Lopate traces the pre-history of the High Line, and ponders whether New York City's elevated park will be a victim of its own success.

Lunch with the Critics: Supertall
On Places, Alexandra Lange and Mark Lamster debate the merits of Supertall!, the latest exhibition at New York City's Skycraper Museum.

The Art of Advocacy: The Museum as Design Laboratory
On Places, MoMA's curator of architecture and design, Barry Bergdoll, describes his efforts to expand the museum's role to support experimentation and advocacy.

Queer Beacon
On Places, architect Kian Goh explores LGBT public spaces in contemporary New York, where activism confronts gentrification.

Gita Lenz: New York Views
On Places, a gallery by the mid-century New York photographer Gita Lenz, whose long neglected work is gaining new recognition.

Jane Jacobs, Andy Warhol, and the Kind of Problem a Community Is
On Places, Tim Mennel compares the radically different New York worlds of Andy Warhol's Factory and Jane Jacobs's Village — and comes to some provocative conclusions.

Jane Jacobs and the Death and Life of American Planning
On Places, Thomas Campanella evaluates the complex legacy Jane Jacobs, including the ongoing marginalization of the urban planning profession.

Street Cred
On Places, Mimi Zeiger reviews Street Value, the new book about Downtown Brooklyn and the dynamic interplay of shopping and planning, of politics and race and class.

What's Going On in the Garment District?
On Places, an interactive section created by the Brooklyn-based Interboro Partners offers a detailed look at "what's going on in the garment district" of Manhattan.

Hallowed Ground, Worldly City: Ground Zero and the Struggle for Lower Manhattan
On Places, James Sanders looks at the current controversy over the proposed Islamic center near Ground Zero in a larger context, noting that New York City has for most of its history "abhorred the very idea of memorials." 

Lunch with the Critics: Park51 & 15 Penn
"Lunch with the Critics," a new feature on Design Observer: Mark Lamster and Alexandra Lange travel to midtown to visit the Hotel Pennsylvania, across from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden.

Lunch with the Critics: The New Lincoln Center
"Lunch with the Critics," a new feature on Design Observer, begins with Alexandra Lange and Mark Lamster's visit to the recently revamped Lincoln Center.

The Water Underground
On Places, watch The Water Underground, a video from the Center for Urban Pedagogy that tracks the complex — and contested — systems of water supply, treatment and waste that serve New York City.

Green Metropolis
On Places, urban planning professor Timothy Beatley, author of Green Urbanism, reviews Green Metropolis, by David Owen, which argues that Manhattan is the greenest city in the U.S.

Adventure Playground: John V. Lindsay and the Transformation of Modern New York
On Places, James Sanders on the transformation of New York City that began in the Sixties under Mayor John Lindsay — the reinvention of the city from a workaday zone to a scenic setting for urban play, an "adventure playground."

Two Feet High and Rising: On Optimism, Speculation and Oysters
On Places, Mimi Zeiger reviews MoMA's ambitious new architecture and urban design show, Rising Currents: Projects for New York's Waterfront, which explores how New York Harbor might be adapted in the face of rising sea levels.

The City's End
Architect Beth Weinstein reviews The City's End: Two Centuries of Fantasies, Fears and Premonitions of New York's Destruction, by architectural historian Max Page — just in time for the season premiere of 24, which finds Jack Bauer and his fellow counter-terrorists relocated to NYC.

Bodega Down Bronx
Why is it easier to get fresh produce in Park Slope than in the South Bronx? Places presents Bodega Down Bronx, a video from the Center for Urban Pedagogy, that examines where and why New York's bodegas get their food.

The Past Is Promenade: On the High Line
Architect Ian Baldwin contemplates the High Line and sees in New York's newest park a rare and valuable form of urban place: a slow corridor.

On the Water: The New York/New Jersey Harbor
As the planet warms, rising seas will endanger coastal communities around the world. Engineer Guy Nordenson proposes a bold plan to protect New York City.