Places

About
Foundation
Partner Schools
Print Archive
Peer Review
Submissions
Donate
Contact


Departments

Critique
Essays
Gallery
Interviews
Multimedia
Partner News
Peer Reviewed
Poetry & Fiction
Projects


Topics

Architecture
Art
Books
Cities + Places
Community
Culture
Design History
Design Practice
Development
Ecology
Economy
Education
Energy
Environment
Film + Video
Food
Geography
Health + Safety
History
Housing
Ideas
Infrastructure
Landscape
Photography
Planning
Politics + Policy
Preservation
Public + Private
Reputations
Sustainability
Technology
Transportation
Urbanism
Water



Design Observer

About
Books
Job Board
Newsletters
Archive
Contact




Gallery: Max Page & Paul Johansen

Landmarks of Punishment: Eastern State and Charles Street




From the Northwest Ordinance of 1787 (which laid out the square-mile grid that structured settlement west of the Mississippi) to the McMillan Plan of 1901 (which created the National Mall in Washington), from Greek revival houses to Victorian homes, from City Beautiful parkways to mental institutions and prisons, American architecture has pursued various national ideals through the careful organization of space for public and private life. Perhaps more than any other Western nation, the United States has tried to solve social problems through architecture. The reform instinct — the belief that the design of residences, institutions and even entire cities should consciously aim to influence behavior — is arguably more pervasive here than anywhere else.




Today, American cities remain littered with the physical remains of successive reform movements — with constructions of brick, stone and steel that embody long-past ideals. The photographs presented here describe and interpret two of the most impressive of these artifacts. The Eastern State Penitentiary, constructed in 1829 in Philadelphia, and the Charles Street Jail, completed in Boston in 1851, were among the most influential and controversial U.S. prison structures in the 19th century.

Eastern State Penitentiary pioneered what became known as the “Pennsylvania Plan” — a revolutionary design organized around a "panopticon rotunda," with eight radiating wings housing individual cells. As such, Eastern State embodied contemporary attitudes about the nature of crime and human behavior — attitudes considered progressive at the time. The designers of Eastern State believed that prisoners placed in solitary confinement would be compelled to contemplate their misdeeds, seek Christian forgiveness, and learn new and more productive ways to conduct themselves — and that in this way they might successfully rejoin society. The prison's architect, John Haviland, created an imposing, Gothic-style structure with exterior stone walls thirty feet high, and with a massive tower at the center of it all, symbolizing the watchful eye of the prison guard, and of the state.

The Charles Street Jail typified another of the era's penal reform movements. The proponents of what became known as the "Auburn Plan," named after a prison built in 1820 in Auburn, New York, rejected the notion of strict solitary confinement; instead they believed that days spent in silent community, with inmates working alongside one other, followed by evenings spent in individual cells, would be the more humanitarian treatment. Designed by the architect Gridley J.F. Bryant, the cruciform building with a central tower — a prime example of Boston's "granite style" — influenced the spatial organization of numerous U.S. prisons in the late 19th and 20th century.




Today, of course, the penal philosophies that animated both Eastern State Penitentiary and Charles Street Jail have been discredited. Even in its day Eastern State provoked debate, with many arguing that solitary confinement and panoptical observation were dehumanizing, and that they made inmates insane. Charles Dickens, who visited the prison on his American tour of 1842, called the system "cruel and wrong." If not as notorious as Eastern State, the Auburn-influenced prisons were characterized by codes of rigid discipline, with corporal punishment used to break the will of the hardest criminals. Today both structures have been transformed. Eastern State, which ceased penal operations in 1971, is now a popular tourist attraction (its seasonal calendar includes a Halloween-themed event). Charles Street, which officially closed in 1990, has been gutted and transformed into the heart of a luxurious hotel.

In his 1922 study of collective memory, the French philosopher Maurice Halbwachs argued, "A society first of all needs to find landmarks." [1] Halbwachs was no sentimental lover of old buildings; rather, he believed that landmarks were essential to creating and perpetuating the collective record that made a society cohere and endure. We offer these photographs — taken in the 1990s, when the fate of these structures was uncertain — as a significant but troubling record of the struggle to devise forms for coping with that most difficult of social problems: how to punish and reform those who transgress the rules of society. We also hope that our photographs will spur further thought about our contemporary prison ethos. These days we rarely speak of "rehabilitation," and the word "penitence" has become antiquated. Arguably, we no longer aspire to construct prisons along humane or reformist lines. We no longer build prisons in central cities but out of town, and out of sight, where we can ignore them and the social divisions and inequities they now reinforce. And yet we continue, even in this era of deep government retrenchment, to invest in prisons; they threaten to be among the major public landmarks of our age.


Credits

The photographs of Eastern State Penitentiary and Charles Street Jail are part of the collection of Iguana Photo

Notes


1. Maurice Halbwachs, On Collective Memory, trans. Lewis Coser (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992). 
Share This Story

RELATED POSTS


Demedicalize Architecture


The Last Days of Kaixian


Ecologies of Gold: The Past and Future Mining Landscapes of Johannesburg


Soundscapes: Atlantikwall


Above Grade: On the High Line



RSSSubscribe to Comment Feed

Comments (1)   |   JUMP TO MOST RECENT >>

The term "moral architecture" is often applied to 19th century prisons, including Eastern State. (see David Rothman's "The Discovery of the Asylum") How can a prison, then or now, be called a "moral" or "good" design, if it functions to practice capital punishment ?

A radial plan, (Eastern State,) is not a true panopticon; it lacks a view into every cell from a central station.
Arthur Allen, retired architect, Vancouver, B.C.
11.04.10 at 12:36



LOG IN TO POST A COMMENT
Don't have an account? Create an account. Forgot your password? Click here.

Email


Password




Donate to Places: Your Support Makes Our Work Possible



ABOUT THE SLIDESHOW

A portfolio of images of Eastern State Penitentiary and Charles Street Jail, featuring photographs by Paul Johansen with selected period images.
View Slideshow >>

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Max Page is Professor of Architecture and History and Director of Preservation Initiatives at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst.

More Bio >>

Paul Johansen has been a violinist, a middle school math teacher, and a Shakespearean actor; he is currently studying criminal justice. 

More Bio >>

DESIGN OBSERVER JOBS