Partner Schools
Print Archive
Peer Review


Partner News
Peer Reviewed
Poetry & Fiction


Cities + Places
Design History
Design Practice
Film + Video
Health + Safety
Politics + Policy
Public + Private

Design Observer

Job Board

Gallery: Michael Lundgren, Aaron Rothman & Josh Wallaert

If There Be Such Space

Photo by Aaron Rothman
Aaron Rothman, Exposed, 2008.

Crouched in the broken shadow with the sun at his back and holding the trap at eyelevel against the morning sky he looked to be truing some older, some subtler instrument. Astrolabe or sextant. Like a man bent at fixing himself someway in the world. Bent on trying by arc or chord the space between his being and the world that was. If there be such space. If it be knowable.
—Cormac McCarthy, The Crossing

There are few exchanges more thrilling than conversation with someone who knows how to read a particular landscape. If you hang around the West long enough, you run into these people — geologists, botanists, firefighters, river guides — and by long enough, I mean ten or twenty minutes. No sooner have you arrived in a new town than you’ve met an alfalfa farmer who can identify tractors by the sound of their engines, or a desert ecologist who names forb species and military aircraft with equal skill. (Nevada will do that to a person.) Before lunch, you’ve met our most common variety of expert, the real estate developer, whose unique genius is to read the conditions of a site and imagine its material transformation, figuring out where the rocks will be dynamited and the water feature installed, an ability which never fails to impress, even as it sometimes appalls.

By sundown in this Western town, you’ve met an artist, likely an environmental artist, a role synonymous these days with a kind of citizen interpreter of landscape. This is a golden age for geography in art, and its artifacts range from embarrassing to inspired. We embroider birds on pillows and use historical maps for découpage; we also write gorgeous poems whose lines re-enact processes of geological transformation, engineer mobile apps that enable hikers to identify the Latin names of plants, and exhibit photographs of altered landscapes that challenge old notions about the dichotomy of built and natural environment. The artist invites the audience to participate in an active reading and interpretation of landscape. We all want to read the world these days, or, more often, have the world read to us.

These exchanges are thrilling, yes, but also dazzling — as in, they can make you go blind. An afternoon hike with a naturalist friend can feel like immersion in a hypertextual, augmented reality, where the names of wildflowers hang, shimmering, in the desert air. It’s exhausting. I have often longed for the mute world I knew as a child: where a rock was a rock and a tree was a tree, and none of it spoke to me, except through direct perception and experience. Nature offers this still, if we are willing to accept it: the blank, unreadable, unbeautiful, apolitical moment. There have been times, when I found myself staring at exposed rock on the side of a hill, that I have known something about its formation; and times when I was accompanied by a scientist or artist who was obliged to translate. But there have been many more unreadable moments, when I could comprehend nothing in that open face of the world but its presence, when I had only the desire to climb the wall or poke at it with a sharp stick.

Maybe that’s why my living room feels agreeably unsettled this month, with photographs by Michael Lundgren and Aaron Rothman tacked to the wall where a map of the West used to be. These artists don’t seem to want to read the world to me. They want to open a space where I can read the world within myself. If there be such space. If it be knowable.

How it can be opened is the primary concern. The physical world abounds with methods for opening space. Holes can be dug or blasted, surfaces lifted or peeled. Fences can be cut, locks pried, corks pulled. Wood rots and water erodes. Artists have less precise tools for opening a space adjacent to the world, and many seem to have abandoned the effort. They assume such space is open already — that viewers encounter their work, unmediated, from the other side of the valley. Or they close whatever space begins to crack, drawing a direct line from the idea to its representation, pulling the line taut, as if suturing a wound.

So when Aaron Rothman forces me to confront an exposed rock wall, my first response is to read the landscape in the photograph as I have heard others read to me. I investigate horizontal and vertical lines that tell stories about flood, erosion, landflow. I study a tree root emerging from the hillside and grasses that seem to hang from the lower rock. And when that reading fails, I retreat to my childhood posture, the explorer facing the mute world. But Rothman doesn’t let me rest so easily. A thin blur moves across the bottom of the picture, or rises from the ground, or advances toward me from the hill. It could be fog or smoke, or darkroom artifact, or digital manipulation. The thin blurred line heightens the unreality of the image and opens a space between the landscape and its representation, or between the representation and my perception. I stand facing my living room wall, focusing my eyes on the plane of the photographic print, then on the plane of the image, and then on the plane of the space between the image and myself. With some practice, I can hold that focus even as I turn away from the wall. If there be such space.

Photo by Michael Lundgren
Michael Lundgren, Chuparosa, 2010.

This focus breaks as soon as I look at one of Michael Lundgren’s photographs, a flowering shrub encountered at night. Some other space has opened here — not between me and the image, but within the image, as if it exists on two planes, such space between the flash of the camera and the photographed object. I rack my brain for the name of this biological organism — chuparosa? — but can’t get through to knowledge of the plant itself, where it grows or how it smells or what it feels like to the touch. What fills the field of view is not the shrub itself, nor a representation of the shrub, but rather an electrically charged expression of the shrub, a plant abstracted into flares of bright green and red and synapses of sharp white.

There is a constructive tension in the work of these two photographers: Lundgren’s visceral transformation of totemic objects — bone and hide and branch — that arrest the viewer’s attention; Rothman’s unreliable landscapes that lack any focal point where the eye might naturally rest. Resolving that tension means accepting a certain responsibility, a willingness to be transformed by the experience of viewing a photographic exhibition. Each artist, in his own way, fixes the viewer in a moment of perception, in an act of misreading the world — which, of course, all readings are.

Such space, once opened, requires our full attention and consciousness, because this is a mode of approaching landscape that we haven’t rehearsed. It’s easy to summon large feeling when we’ve arrived at a waterfall or canyon rim, when we’ve climbed a high pass to look out on a majestic valley transformed by industrial use, or when we’ve seen these landscapes rendered earnestly in a work of art. But the world requires us to read more carefully. More hiking trails should end in a bright flash of scrub brush or an unfathomable rock wall. If it be knowable. The next time we go walking, reader, I’ll be thinking about that.

—Josh Wallaert

Editors' Note

If There Be Such Space
will be exhibited at the University of Virginia, in the Ruffin Gallery, January 27 to February 17, 2012. The exhibition is sponsored by the McIntire Department of Art and curated by William Wylie, Professor of Art at the University of Virginia.

Lundgren and Rothman discuss the installation with Wylie in a feature at
Share This Story


TEDification versus Edification


Detroit Re-Photography

Is This Place Great or What

L.A. Day/L.A. Night

RSSSubscribe to Comment Feed

Comments (1)   |   JUMP TO MOST RECENT >>

Stunning, I'd read the article and watch the pictures again and again.
amrina bar
02.05.12 at 11:54

Don't have an account? Create an account. Forgot your password? Click here.



Donate to Places: Your Support Makes Our Work Possible


Photographs by Michael Lundgren and Aaron Rothman.
View Slideshow >>


Josh Wallaert is the associate editor of Places. He lives in San Francisco.
More Bio >>

Aaron Rothman’s photographs, video and installation artwork explore perceptual experience of space in both natural and built environments.
More Bio >>

Michael Lundgren teaches photography at Arizona State University and is the author of Transfigurations and co-author of After the Ruins: Rephotographing the San Francisco Earthquake.
More Bio >>


MORE ON American West

From the American West to West Berlin
On Places, Nicole Huber and Ralph Stern explore the "border crossings" of Wim Wenders — the director's cinematic journeys from Paris, Texas to the West Berlin of The Wings of Desire.

800 Miles: Photographing the Trans-Alaska Pipeline
On Places, a portfolio of photographs by Peter Bo Rappmund, who has documented nearly every mile of the Trans-Alaska oil pipeline.

Heavy Metal
On Places, photographer Dennis DeHart traces the Trail of the Coeur d'Alenes through one of the world's largest and most contaminated historic mining districts.

Look Only at the Movement
On Places, a documentary project by Jamie Kruse and Elizabeth Ellsworth of Smudge Studio, focusing on the materiality of nuclear waste transport.

Walking the Darkness Home
On Places, Adelheid Fischer recounts a journey to the Grand Canyon — to a dangerous and redemptive place that by turns epitomizes and defies the expectations (and clichés) of the famous landscape.

Resurveying the West
On Places, a slideshow of images of the American West by the New York-based photographer Victoria Sambunaris and the 19th-century pioneer William Henry Jackson, curated by Aaron Rothman.

Camino del Diablo
On Places, photographer Mark Klett journeys along the Camino del Diablo in the Sonoran Desert, much of which is now a bombing range, and finds a landscape of forbidding danger and compelling beauty.

Nowhere and Everywhere: The Landscape of the Colorado Delta
On Places, planner Armando Carbonell explores, in aerial photographs, the fragile yet resilient landscapes of the Colorado River Delta.

Above Lake Las Vegas
On Places, aerial photographs of the bankrupt luxury communities of Lake Las Vegas, by Michael Light.

We Are in a Western Town
On Places, Aaron Rothman explores the enduring power of the photographs of Robert Adams, and what they reveal about the paradoxical landscape of the American West.

Drylands: Water and the West
On Places, an essay and slideshow by Peter Arnold and Hadley Arnold of the Arid Lands Institute, on what they call "the largest and least understood environmental challenge of the 21st century."

Thirsty City
On Places, Austin Troy assesses the massive infrastructure required to bring water to the arid American West — and the huge amount of energy that makes it possible to take a shower in Los Angeles.

The Hills Are Alive
On Places, Michael Branch reflects on how deeply photography and film shape our landscape aesthetics (and how much he detests the Alpine-worshipping The Sound of Music).

Bird on Fire: Lessons from the World's Least Sustainable City
On Places, Andrew Ross analyzes the contradictory political and economic forces that once made Phoenix the fastest-growing city in the U.S. — and today a prime casualty of the crash.

Water in the West
On Places, a slideshow from the collaborative photography project Water in the West, with an introduction by Mark Klett.

The Half-Life of History
On Places, writer William Fox and photographer Mark Klett document the semi-ruin of the WW II military airfield at Wendover, Utah, where the U.S. Air Force trained for the bombing of Hiroshima.

Views Across Time
On Places, an interview with photographer Mark Klett and a slideshow from his ongoing rephotography project, with views across time of the American West.

The Edge of Light: Wendover
On Places, photographs by Brian Rosa and Adam Ryder document the nighttime mysteries of Wendover, where military history, land-speed racing and the casino industry make for unexpected juxtapositions.

Soundscapes: Burning Man
On Places, a selection of soundscapes — ranging from dust storms to diesel generators — recorded by architect Nick Sowers at the latest Burning Man.

Burning Man and the Metropolis
On Places, Nate Berg looks at Burning Man, and how a beach party in San Francisco mushroomed into a week-long temporary city of 50,000 out in the Nevada desert.

Land, Speed and Bonneville
On Places — coinciding with Speed Week at Bonneville — a gallery created by architect Martin Hogue documents decades of land speed racing on the Bonneville Salt Flats of western Utah.

Las Vegas
Writer and critic William L. Fox reviews Las Vegas, by Nicole Huber and Ralph Stern, probing the improbable success of the gambling-entertainment world-city constructed in the midst of the Mojave.

Urbanizing the Mojave
America's greatest boomtown has gone bust. Architects Nicole Huber and Ralph Stern explore the cultural and environmental consequences of the rapid expansion of Las Vegas into the Mojave Desert, tracing a troubled history of mining, militarization, tourism, and water politics.